We all know that the Pirate broadcast booth is nothing more than a mouthpiece for Bob Nutting trying to convince the public that the Pirates are better than they really are. If you had listened to the opening of the Pirate broadcast over the years and never watched a game, you would have thought that the Pirates had won many division titles and a couple of World Series. Let’s face it, they have to answer to their boss just like everybody else. It is especially bad when your boss is one of the worst owners in baseball. But even allowing for all of that, I still think it is wrong when you cherry pick data or ignore certain aspects of the data just to make the Pirates look good. There were two recent examples of this. One was just a statement that was not backed up. The other was how good the Pirates record was against teams that are over .500. Here are the two examples of Pirate Propaganda.
It was stated by Joe Block that this team is the greatest hitting team in Pirate history. There is one way of looking at this that will show that the 2026 Pirates are the best hitting team in the team’s history. They beat every team when the hitting statistics of each past Pirate team includes the pitchers who batted until the DH came to the National League. Fortunately, Baseball Reference keeps data on teams that does not include the pitchers batting. Granted there were some pitchers on the Pirates over the years that batted better than Henry Davis but that is not the point. There are two ways of looking at how well a team hits. The raw number of OPS and the comparison number of OPS+ which takes into consideration the overall hitting environment of that particular year. There is no question that this current crop of Pirate hitters are having one great season so far. Their current OPS is .768. There were four Pirate teams that finished their seasons with a higher OPS. The 1979, 1960, 1925 and 1927 Pirates all had a higher OPS. The 1990, 1992, 1976, and the 1972 Pirates had an OPS over .750 but below .768. The current Pirate hitters have an OPS+ 110. The 1925 team had an OPS+ of 111. The 1972 Pirates were at 114. The 1990 and 91 Pirates were 113 and 115 respectively. There is the possibility that the 2026 Pirates may surpass these teams. They could go in the other direction too, and there would be some other teams that would past them. This team is doing amazing things at the plate, but they are not the greatest hitting team in Pirate history, at least for the moment.
The second stat the broadcast booth put out that was misleading was the Pirates record against clubs with a winning record. I wish I had copied it down now, but it was several games above .500. In other words it was pretty good or it would have never been brought up. Just because you played at the time a team that was over .500 does not mean that it was a good team especially early in the season. The Pirates have played 9 teams that if the postseason started tomorrow would be in the playoffs. They are the Dodgers, Brewers, Braves, Cubs, Phillies and Marlins in the National League. In the American League it is the Rays, Rangers, and Mariners. Against those teams the Pirates record is 19-22. In my view not a bad record but not above .500. The Pirates first games after the All Star break are against the Guardians and Yankees two other teams that would be in the playoffs. That record will be changing quickly once the season starts up again. As I wrote before this is part of the job description for being a Pirate broadcaster. I watch the Padres broadcasts when I am in San Diego. They give a much better balanced view of the team. The Padres have been struggling this year especially their big stars. They do not try and hide or sugar coat that fact. Of course, the Padres have been trying to win games and make the playoffs for the last 7 years. You cannot say that about the Pirates. Tomorrow I will look at the remaining 65 game schedule and the trade deadline.
