The Pirates have had their most active off-season in about 10 years. They will open the season with new players at 5 positions. Some of those players will be in-house, but nonetheless, they are not the players that played those positions on opening day. Their last acquisition, Marcell Ozuna, changed the whole dynamic of the team. Before this signing, I felt that the DH role would be pretty much by committee. It is a moot point now because Ozuna will be the full-time DH, if for no other reason than by default. This eliminates any possibility that the Pirates will sign McCutchen. All we can do is look at this team in its present state as spring training opens. In order to see how much the Pirates have improved, we will use one raw stat, OPS. This is the combination of on-base percentage added to the slugging percentage. This gives the total picture of how somebody is contributing to the offense of the team. I am not going to get into the comparison stat of OPS+. This takes in a lot of factors that could be argued. It is time to look at just the numbers. Let us see how this current Pirate team stacks up at the moment.
The players that are going to be playing the same position as they did last year will be the catching tandem of Joey Bart and Henry Davis. The other three will be Oneil Cruz CF, Bryan Reynolds RF, and Spencer Horwitz 1st base. Brandon Lowe will be the 2nd baseman. He will replace Nick Gonzales. Lowe’s OPS was .784 in 2025, compared to Gonzales’ at .661, an improvement of 123 points. Jared Triolo is set to start at 3rd base, replacing Ke’Bryan Hayes. Believe it or not, this will also be quite the upgrade. Triolo is at .667, while Hayes, when he was with the Pirates, was a pathetic .569, a 98-point improvement. At shortstop will be Gonzales. Gonzales will be a slight upgrade from Isiah Kiner-Falefa. Kiner-Falefa, despite the propaganda from the Pirate booth, was not all that productive with an OPS of .632. Neither one is anything to write home about, but the fact remains that Gonzales is a slight upgrade. In left field will be Ryan O’Hearn. He is replacing Tommy Pham. O’Hearn tops Pham .803 to .700, a 103-point increase. Last but certainly not least, Marcell Ozuna will be replacing Andrew McCutchen at the DH slot. Ozuna is a moderate upgrade from McCutchen with an OPS of .756 to McCutchen’s .700. There will be some that argue the Pirates are sacrificing defense for this decided upgrade in offense. A closer inspection shows that 2nd base, 3rd base, and shortstop grade out about the same between the players. The big difference is in left field, where Pham was a Gold Glove finalist, and O’Hearn is a decidedly below-average defender in left field. He is a very good fielding 1st baseman. The other caveat here is that these players have to at least repeat their offensive production of 2025. Although that is not a given, they could also improve upon their 2025 season. I really think that it is a flip of the coin which will happen. It will certainly determine how successful this 2026 season will be.
The Pirates can still make some moves. There are certain players that are expendable. The Pirates have prospects that teams should have an interest in. The other thing that the Ozuna signing did was practically guarantee that Rafael Flores will not go north with the team. Flores was the main piece in the David Bednar trade with the Yankees. He can play 1st base and catcher. This makes him, Bart, Davis, and Horwitz all expendable. The next expendable group would be Triolo, Gonzales, and Reynolds. Konnor Griffin and Password make them expendable. If the Pirates really wanted to make a bold move, they could move Oneil Cruz. Any of the above should bring in a good offensive 3rd baseman. What will the Pirates finally wind up doing with Jack Suwinski and Endy Rodriguez? Acquiring Ozuna took a lot of the flexibility out of the Pirate lineup. We will see if that turns out to be a good or a bad thing. The Pirates must feel that DH should be a full-time position. I must say that they may be right, but there is not a lot of data on that. Their lack of lineup flexibility does give them a lot of trade flexibility. Only time will tell, but it certainly looks like the Pirates have one or two more moves to make. We can only hope that they will be good ones.
