The Pirates last year had one of the best pitching staffs in all of baseball. That is the key phrase, one of the best. They had THE WORST OFFENSE in all of baseball, 2nd to none. This stat sums it up best. The Pirate pitchers had the 7th best ERA in baseball. Every team that had a worse ERA than the Pirates had a better record except for 4 teams. The Chicago White Sox 20th, the Minnesota Twins 24th, the Washington Nationals 29th and the Colorado Rockies 30th. The Pirates led the league in shutouts last year throwing 19. Twenty seven per cent of their wins were by shutout, the highest percentage in the league. The Pirates have lost 2 pitchers Johan Oviedo and Mike Burrows in exchange for more offense. Even though I have a sinking feeling that the Burrow loss may come back to haunt them, I do not criticize the trade. The Pirates had to do something. The staff looks still very strong. I will look at who I think should be there on opening day with the current crop of pitchers on the 40 man roster. That leaves Jared Jones off this list, but you know he will be returning sometime this year. We will include Jose Urquidy who is now on the 40 man roster.
I am going to do this a little differently. Instead of looking at the rotation and then the bullpen, I am just going to go down the list of players and decide where they will fit in and how likely that is to happen. Most likely, the Pirates will take 13 pitchers north when camp breaks. Who will those 13 be? Keeper No. 1, Braxton Ashcraft will be in the starting rotation. As long as he can avoid having control issues, he will probably be considered the no. 3 starter. Keeper no. 2, Hunter Barco, in my view, is the best candidate to hold down the 5th spot in the rotation. That could change if the Pirates add a veteran lefty. Even if that happens, I would keep him in the bullpen. Brandan Bidois had a great minor league run last year coming out of the bullpen. Not that likely to make the team, but he will be a great depth addition if injuries do come up. He was protected from the Rule 5 draft. Keeper No.3, Bubba Chandler will be in the starting rotation. Expect him to be the no. 2 starter. When he finally made it to the majors, he was spectacular. Wilber Dotel, another young strong arm for the Pirates, was protected from the Rule 5 draft. Again, nice depth, will start in the minors. Ryan Harbin, another Rule 5 protection, will start the season in AAA. Thomas Harrington had a rough 2025. He had a brief look at the MLB level and got knocked around pretty good. Unless there are injuries or he has a spectacular spring, he will start in AAA. He does have starter potential. Keeper No.4, Mitch Keller will be in the starting rotation. There is always hope that Keller will pitch as well as the Pirate broadcast booth says he pitches. They make him out to be another Walter Johnson. Even though he is not close to that, he is a solid average Major League starter, and that is nothing to sneeze at. He had the worst run support of any pitcher. Antwone Kelly, another young arm the Pirates have. He will start in the minors. Keeper No. 5, Justin Lawrence will be a solid bullpen member. In his first season, he had an injury that limited his innings. Hopefully, that is just a fluke. If he remains healthy, he will be a great high-leverage guy. Keeper no. 6, Isaac Mattson had a breakout year last year. Even if this was a fluke, there are plenty of arms to replace him, but I feel he is the real deal. Keeper no. 7, Carmen Mlodzinski. This is simple: bullpen yes, starting rotation no. Keeper no.8, Mason Montgomery. Left-handed bullpen addition. If the Pirates can get his control issues fixed, he will be awesome. Keeper no.9, Kyle Nicolas. Another pitcher who has great stuff, but location is a problem. If that is corrected he will be excellent. Yohan Ramirez. Simply no. I don’t know why they signed him. Even if there are injuries, I would choose the young guys before I would let him on the field. Cam Sanders and Evan Sisk are two left-handers who have been replaced. Keeper No.10, Dennis Santana. This is one of those guys who just goes along and quietly does his job. It is hard to say what the Pirates will do when it comes to closing. I would hope that they do it by committee. I feel that way is the best way. Having said that, I still will not mind it if the closer turns out to be Santana. Keeper no. 11, Paul Skenes, simply the ace of the United States. Keeper no. 12, Gregory Soto, the other lefty acquisition that should be a big upgrade coming out of the bullpen. Keeper no. 13, Jose Urquidy, certainly adds versatility to the staff. I see him coming out of the bullpen and making spot starts.
The wild card in all of this is the new pirate pitching coach, Bill Murphy. He comes from the pitching guru Houston Astros. He has been a big part of the pitching philosophy since 2017. Hopefully, he brings this successful philosophy with him. There is no question the 13 pitchers that are most likely to make this team have elite stuff. The issue has been putting that stuff where they want it. His 3 big projects should be Kyle Nicolas, Mason Montgomery, and the veteran Justin Lawrence. Believe it or not, Nicolas is the best of the group with a walk rate of 10.8%. Montgomery is at 12.9% and Lawrence is at 12.4%. If this pitching coach can find a way for these guys to get down to about 7 or 8%, this bullpen is going to be first-class. This is what makes Bubba Chandler so good. His walk rate is an amazing 3.2%. He is better than Skenes in that department, who has a 5.7% walk rate. Even though I think these are the 13 pitchers that will make the team at the moment, there is little room for error for this group. The young arms the Pirates have are chomping at the bit. The Pirates are not deep enough that they could absorb a slew of injuries, but they could weather a moderate storm for sure. Despite the upgrade on offense, the pitching is where this team is as strong as any in baseball. They will be even stronger when Jones returns. Their offense was solidly entrenched in 30th place last year. There was not another offense that was close to being as bad as they were. If they can improve to 16th to 19th, just below average, they will have a shot at the division.
