We are about 40% into the season and the Pirates continue to swim in the waters of mediocrity. It is amazing how consistently mediocre they are in all phases of the game, except one. Their starting pitching is now ranked 6th in all of baseball according to wins above replacement. All other parts of their team are ranked anywhere from 11th to 25th. The Pirates have played 33 games since the last evaluation of the team. Amazingly they have a record of 17-16. It is amazing because in every important team category they have gotten worse or essentially stayed the same. In runs scored they went from 21st to 20th. In on base percentage they went 15th to 24th. In the comparison stat of OPS+ they went from 24th to 27th. What this tells us, that despite all the rhetoric in the Pirate broadcast booth, the offense still stinks and has gotten worse. On the run prevention side of the ball the Pirates have fallen also, but not quite as far. In runs allowed the Pirates went from 15th to 19th. In fielding independent pitching, they went from 17th to 19th. In the comparison stat ERA+ they went from 12th to 14th. In an area where I thought they would be strong, fielding, they fell from 12th to 17th in defensive efficiency. This team is about as mediocre as a team can get, which I guess is better than being awful.
As a refresher, the comparison stat of OPS+ and ERA+ is just a number with 100 being league average. Henry Davis 38, Jarod Triolo 66, Rowdy Tellez 67, Michael Taylor 44, Jack Suwinski 63, and Yasmani Grandal 33 are the reason that the Pirates are so bad on offense. Only Rowdy Tellez is beginning to show some signs of life. You knew what you were getting with Michael Taylor, an elite center fielder who has been an up and down hitter his whole career. However, Suwinski, Davis, and Triolo have been major disappointments. Once Joey Bart and Ji Hwan Bae get healthy Davis and Suwinski should be back in AAA. Triolo should be sent down and Liover Peguero should be given another shot. On the pitching side of the ball 4 of the starting pitchers have solid ERA+. Mitch Keller 130, Paul Skenes 138, Jared Jones 126, and Barry Falter 111. The bullpen has been the obvious problem. At one time they were ranked as low as 28th in baseball but have been able to pull up to 23rd at the 65 game mark. The top of the bullpen, the A team as I like to call them, of Bednar, Holderman and Chapman have performed well over the last 2 weeks. As much as I like to get on Hunter Stratton he does have an ERA+ of 96 which should keep him on the team for now. The two that have to go are Kyle Nicolas 67 and Ben Heller 10. I really do not know what the Pirates have against Jose Hernandez. When given the opportunity he has done all right. Carmen Mlodzinski has an ERA+ of 72 but has pitched better lately. The Pirates need to replace Nicolas and Heller now.
As I wrote before, it is amazing that the Pirates played one game over .500 during this stretch of games. The next evaluation will be at the All Star break. We will see what if any moves the Pirates make. It is obvious that they need bullpen help. I do not care where they get it, but something has to be done with either 2 or even 3 relievers being replace immediately. Even though the starting pitching of the Pirates is approaching elite status, in this day and age this only gets you through 2/3 of the game. Without a shutdown bullpen you are not going to make any kind of run at a playoff spot, even in the mediocre National League. Forty per cent through the season and the Pirates are still right in the hunt for the last wild card spot. It would be so easy to put this team over the top. They need one solid batter and two good, not great, relievers. Please management do something for once. I am not getting any younger.
